Kelly J
09-28-2012, 08:50 AM
Part two: BIDS vs NICS
Read the original Puckett and Howard paper here.
Key differences between BIDS and NICS:
BIDS
NICS
Check performed by:
Private federally licensed dealer
Government agents
Possession of data for check:
Dealer encrypted files, via NCIC and III
Secret government repository
Type of Check:
Local query: Is buyer on list of people with firearms-purchase disabilities?
Based upon all categories listed in
18 USC §922(d), (g) and (n).
Centralized query: Is buyer on list of people with firearms-purchase disabilities? Save query data.
Based upon all categories listed in
18 USC §922(d), (g) and (n).
Privacy
Reason for disability is not included.
Use for any other purpose carries serious penalties.
Prohibited person status alone is not privileged information, OK to use
Reason for disability is not disclosed
Use for any other purpose carries serious penalties.
Prohibited person status in files is privileged information
Accuracy
Precisely as good as the FBI data provided on prohibited persons, and dealer compliance.
Precisely as good as the FBI data provided on prohibited persons, and dealer compliance.
Compliance
Dealer failure to comply is a serious crime, subjects dealer to loss of license, fines and imprisonment.
Easily verified by ATF visits which dealers currently agree to in obtaining license to operate.
Dealer failure to comply is a serious crime, subjects dealer to loss of license, fines and imprisonment.
Easily verified by ATF visits which dealers currently agree to in obtaining license to operate.
Cost
Extremely low: some startup, initial training, periodic data transmission to dealer sites
Extremely high: huge infrastructure, equipment needs, ongoing office space and staffing, support facilities and personnel, benefits, HR, management.
Ongoing recordkeeping that identifies gun buyers
Dealer maintains routine sales information as with any other retail purchase of merchandise.
Government does not learn in real time who legally buys guns from dealers, removing chances of illegal registrations. Trace data through 4473 forms is addressed by BIDS.
Dealer must keep transactions and buyer identification available for inspection or seizure. Dealers must turn over records to government upon going out of business, high potential for illegal registries. Pervasive legal, illegal & potential registry opportunities with no safeguards or meaningful oversight.
Contact:
Alan Korwin
BLOOMFIELD PRESS
"We publish the gun laws."
4848 E. Cactus #505-440
Scottsdale, AZ 85254
602-996-4020 Phone
602-494-0679 FAX
1-800-707-4020 Orders
http://www.gunlaws.com
alan@gunlaws.com
Call, write, fax or click for a free full-color catalog
Encourage politicians to pass more laws...
with expiration dates.
Complete alphabetical list
Gun LawsGun Rights Gun PoliticsFree SpeechDVDsSelf Defense and Safety
SurvivalPolice GuidesKnivesNovelsThe Founders PackageHistory of Rights
ButtonsRecent Additions 123Women & KidsFirst-Time Gun Owners
Newest ProductsPackage Deals
Home Books National Directory Position Papers Alan’s Blog FAQ New Stuff Search
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
gunlaws.com and bloomfieldpress.com are domains owned by Alan Korwin.
Alan is a nationally recognized author of numerous books
on gun laws and other topics.
If you like this site you'll like his books. Take a look
Read the original Puckett and Howard paper here.
Key differences between BIDS and NICS:
BIDS
NICS
Check performed by:
Private federally licensed dealer
Government agents
Possession of data for check:
Dealer encrypted files, via NCIC and III
Secret government repository
Type of Check:
Local query: Is buyer on list of people with firearms-purchase disabilities?
Based upon all categories listed in
18 USC §922(d), (g) and (n).
Centralized query: Is buyer on list of people with firearms-purchase disabilities? Save query data.
Based upon all categories listed in
18 USC §922(d), (g) and (n).
Privacy
Reason for disability is not included.
Use for any other purpose carries serious penalties.
Prohibited person status alone is not privileged information, OK to use
Reason for disability is not disclosed
Use for any other purpose carries serious penalties.
Prohibited person status in files is privileged information
Accuracy
Precisely as good as the FBI data provided on prohibited persons, and dealer compliance.
Precisely as good as the FBI data provided on prohibited persons, and dealer compliance.
Compliance
Dealer failure to comply is a serious crime, subjects dealer to loss of license, fines and imprisonment.
Easily verified by ATF visits which dealers currently agree to in obtaining license to operate.
Dealer failure to comply is a serious crime, subjects dealer to loss of license, fines and imprisonment.
Easily verified by ATF visits which dealers currently agree to in obtaining license to operate.
Cost
Extremely low: some startup, initial training, periodic data transmission to dealer sites
Extremely high: huge infrastructure, equipment needs, ongoing office space and staffing, support facilities and personnel, benefits, HR, management.
Ongoing recordkeeping that identifies gun buyers
Dealer maintains routine sales information as with any other retail purchase of merchandise.
Government does not learn in real time who legally buys guns from dealers, removing chances of illegal registrations. Trace data through 4473 forms is addressed by BIDS.
Dealer must keep transactions and buyer identification available for inspection or seizure. Dealers must turn over records to government upon going out of business, high potential for illegal registries. Pervasive legal, illegal & potential registry opportunities with no safeguards or meaningful oversight.
Contact:
Alan Korwin
BLOOMFIELD PRESS
"We publish the gun laws."
4848 E. Cactus #505-440
Scottsdale, AZ 85254
602-996-4020 Phone
602-494-0679 FAX
1-800-707-4020 Orders
http://www.gunlaws.com
alan@gunlaws.com
Call, write, fax or click for a free full-color catalog
Encourage politicians to pass more laws...
with expiration dates.
Complete alphabetical list
Gun LawsGun Rights Gun PoliticsFree SpeechDVDsSelf Defense and Safety
SurvivalPolice GuidesKnivesNovelsThe Founders PackageHistory of Rights
ButtonsRecent Additions 123Women & KidsFirst-Time Gun Owners
Newest ProductsPackage Deals
Home Books National Directory Position Papers Alan’s Blog FAQ New Stuff Search
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
gunlaws.com and bloomfieldpress.com are domains owned by Alan Korwin.
Alan is a nationally recognized author of numerous books
on gun laws and other topics.
If you like this site you'll like his books. Take a look